Ductless vs. Ducted Systems: A Comprehensive Comparison for Milwaukee Homeowners

air conditioner

Ductless vs. Ducted Systems: A Comprehensive Comparison for Milwaukee Homeowners

January 3, 2024

Choosing the right heating and cooling system is essential for maintaining a comfortable living environment in your Milwaukee County home. As a homeowner, you have various options, including ductless and ducted systems, each with its unique features and advantages. Understanding the differences between these systems allows you to select the best fit for your home’s specific requirements and preferences. This comprehensive comparison examines the features, installation, efficiency, and maintenance aspects of both ductless and ducted systems, guiding Milwaukee homeowners in making an educated decision.

Ductless vs. Ducted Systems: A Comprehensive Comparison for Milwaukee Homeowners

1. System Overview and Functionality

Ductless Heating and Cooling Systems:

Ductless or mini-split systems consist of an outdoor compressor/condenser and indoor air-handling units connected by refrigerant lines and electrical cables. These systems can deliver heating and cooling to individual rooms or zones within a house, allowing for customizable temperature settings.

Ducted Heating and Cooling Systems:

A ducted system, also known as central heating and air conditioning, features a centrally located indoor unit that heats or cools the air and an outdoor unit that removes or supplies heat, depending on the season. Ductwork is responsible for circulating the conditioned air throughout the home, maintaining a consistent temperature in all rooms.

2. Installation and Retrofitting

Ductless Systems:

Ductless systems are relatively simple and quick to install compared to ducted systems. They require minimal modifications to your home since they only need small holes to run the necessary lines between your outdoor and indoor units. This makes them a popular choice for homeowners looking to retrofit an existing structure or reduce the impact on their home’s appearance during installation.

Ducted Systems:

Ducted systems are more labor-intensive and can be costly to install, as they require ductwork to distribute conditioned air throughout the home. In new construction, the installation process is straightforward and can be integrated into the home’s design. However, retrofitting a ducted system into an existing structure can be complex and time-consuming, often involving significant alterations to walls, ceilings, and floors to accommodate the ductwork.

3. Energy Efficiency and Cost

Ductless Systems:

Mini-split systems are generally more energy-efficient than their ducted counterparts because they use inverter technology to modulate their output in response to temperature changes. By varying the motor’s speed, ductless systems deliver the precise amount of cooling or heating needed, avoiding the on-off cycling of traditional systems. Additionally, the lack of ductwork reduces energy loss through leaks or thermal transmission. As a result, homeowners can expect lower energy bills with ductless systems.

Ducted Systems:

Ducted systems, while less efficient than ductless systems, can still provide excellent energy savings if properly designed, installed, and maintained. Features such as zoning, proper sizing, and regular maintenance can improve overall efficiency. However, ducted systems lose some energy efficiency through air leakage in the ductwork and heat exchange through the duct material. These losses can be minimized by proper insulation and sealing.

4. Aesthetics and Flexibility

Ductless Systems: Ductless systems offer increased flexibility in installation, as indoor units can be mounted in various locations: on walls, floors, or ceilings. Mini-splits come in a variety of styles and designs to suit different room aesthetics, allowing homeowners to choose the best fit for their home’s interior. However, some may find the presence of indoor units visually intrusive compared to a ducted system, which is hidden within the walls. Ducted Systems: For homeowners who prefer a more discreet HVAC solution, ducted systems might be the better option. Since the components are concealed within the walls, all that’s visible in each room are vents and registers, providing a cleaner, more uniform appearance. However, the inclusion of ductwork may limit design possibilities and flexibility in some homes, particularly when retrofitting an existing structure.

5. Air Quality and Maintenance

Ductless Systems:

Ductless systems typically feature advanced air filtration systems that help improve indoor air quality by trapping dust, pollen, and other airborne particles. Because there are no ducts, the system reduces the potential for mold and mildew growth and minimizes the spread of contaminants through the air distribution system. However, regular cleaning of the indoor units’ filters is essential to maintain optimal performance and air quality levels.

Ducted Systems:

While ducted systems are equipped with air filters, they may be less efficient at removing pollutants, especially when ductwork becomes dirty. Ducts may also trap dust, allergens, and bacteria, which can contribute to reduced air quality over time. Routine filter replacement and periodic duct cleaning are crucial to maintaining good air quality in homes with ducted systems.

6. Noise Levels

Ductless Systems:

Ductless systems are usually quieter than ducted ones since the noisiest component – the compressor – is outside the home. Indoor units also employ quiet, variable-speed fans that adjust as needed while minimizing noise.

Ducted Systems:

Ducted systems can generate more noise due to the blower fan, air movement through the ducts, and the expansion and contraction of duct materials. Proper design and installation can help minimize these noises, but ducted systems may still produce more audible disturbances than their ductless counterparts. By considering factors such as installation, energy efficiency, aesthetics, air quality, and noise levels, Milwaukee homeowners can make an informed decision between ductless and ducted systems. Each has its unique advantages and drawbacks, so the choice boils down to your specific requirements, existing home infrastructure, and preferences.

Choose Burkhardt Heating & Cooling for Expert HVAC Solutions

Ultimately, the choice between ductless and ducted heating and cooling systems depends on your individual needs, preferences, and the unique characteristics of your Milwaukee County home. By comparing the advantages and disadvantages of both options, you can make an informed decision on the best system for maintaining a comfortable and efficient living environment. As a trusted provider of HVAC service in Milwaukee, Washington, and Waukesha counties, we at Burkhardt Heating & Cooling are committed to helping Milwaukee homeowners find the best solutions for their homes. Our experienced team can guide you through the selection, installation, and maintenance of your heating and cooling systems, ensuring tailored, reliable solutions for your comfort and efficiency needs. Contact Burkhardt Heating & Cooling today to discuss your HVAC requirements and discover the ideal heating and cooling solutions for your Milwaukee County home.

Share This :

Recent Posts

electrical inspection
Electrical

Your Comprehensive Guide to Residential Electrical Inspections for Safety and Efficiency

As a renowned HVAC service and repair company serving Milwaukee, Washington, and Waukesha counties, Burkhardt Heating & Cooling is committed to providing comprehensive services encompassing not just heating and cooling, ...
Read More
air conditioning system
HVAC

Maximize Your Comfort with High Velocity Air Conditioning Systems: A Complete Guide

As a leading HVAC service and repair company proudly serving Milwaukee, Washington, and Waukesha counties, we’re committed to providing our clients with industry-leading solutions for their indoor comfort needs. One ...
Read More
heat pump
Heat Pump

Discover the Benefits and Efficiency of Heat Pumps for Your Heating System: A Comprehensive Guide

As a premier HVAC service and repair company, serving Milwaukee, Washington, and Waukesha counties, we prioritize delivering top-quality heating solutions that provide reliability, comfort, and energy efficiency for our clients. ...
Read More
air and furnace filter
HVAC

The Importance of Indoor Air Quality and the Role of Air & Furnace Filters

As a top HVAC service and repair company in Milwaukee, Washington, and Waukesha counties, we recognize the crucial role that indoor air quality plays in maintaining a healthy and comfortable ...
Read More